This Technical Bulletin considers in general terms how typically currently worded insurances for U.K. insureds might respond to the Coronavirus outbreak, the exact position will depend upon the specific policy wording. It is also quite possible if the outbreak worsens that for certain classes, such as Business Interruption, insurers may seek to impose Coronavirus coverage restrictions.
For U.K. Employers’ Liability, Public Liability and Business Travel policies, before employees are allowed to travel to the affected areas it would be prudent to advise insurers, via your Broker, of the potential plans so as not to risk being in breach of policy terms.
Business Interruption Policies
A standard U.K. Business Interruption policy is triggered by physical damage to property used by an insured at its premises. Even if it can be argued that actual (not suspected) contamination by Coronavirus is physical damage to property, contamination is generally excluded unless caused by a Defined Peril (i.e. fire and special perils) which would not include accidental contamination, unless the policy has specifically been extended, and then the extended cover could be subject to a sub-limit.
There are several Business Interruption extensions (see below) which, if included in a Business Interruption policy, might possibly afford some coverage, although such extensions are normally subject to fairly modest sub-limits (and sub-limits are often subject to an annual aggregate) and only tend to cover interruption to the business for a relatively short period of time.
In general, these types of extensions are mainly designed for a specific isolated incident occurring at (or sometimes near) an insured location and coverage is often conditional upon an order of closure or limitation of access by the appropriate authorities (though some Infectious Disease extensions only require that there is an “outbreak” at or sometimes near an insured location). Normally the insured location will be limited to the “insured’s premises” but very occasionally this may extend to include suppliers and/or customers premises.
It is worth noting a potentially relevant limitation of standard U.K. Business Interruption cover highlighted in the legal case Orient-Express Hotels v Generali. In this case an insured whose hotel was damaged by hurricanes could not satisfy the “but for” test of causation i.e. even if their hotel had not been damaged, it would have suffered the same Business Interruption loss because of the devastation to the surrounding area, due to the operation of the “trends clause” which would take account of this factor.
There may be arguments that could be raised that such a limitation does not always apply to the Business Interruption cover in so far as it has been extended to cover restrictions
in access to an insured location or loss of attraction, depending upon the circumstances.
Infectious Disease Business Interruption Extension
The most likely relevant extension is an Infectious Disease extension, although traditionally these were included only where an insured had a specific exposure (e.g. hospitality/ leisure industry) but over the years these extensions have become more commonplace. There are a number of aspects clients should bear in mind for these extensions, such as:
Non-Damage Business Interruption Extension
A Non-Damage Business Interruption extension may take the form of either a Denial of Access Non-Damage or a Loss of Attraction Non-Damage (or a combination of both) extension.
These extensions will either exclude disease, in which case there is no cover, or it will be silent on disease. If these extensions are silent, although it may not be the intention of insurers to cover disease, it might still be possible to argue cover applies, if for example the insured location is closed down or sealed off on the instruction or advice of the appropriate statutory body.
Some extensions will require that the reason is because of some sort of danger or disturbance. Some extensions will also apply if the area in the vicinity of the insured location is closed down or sealed off, if so, how is “vicinity” defined (it may not be defined or it may be limited to say X miles, with 1 mile not being uncommon).
Liability Policies:
U.K. Employers’ Liability
U.K. Employers’ Liability policy should respond to cover the insured’s legal liability as employer for any injury or illness suffered by their employees in the course of their employment. Furthermore, many policies extend to cover temporary overseas business travel.
There are few or no exclusions in a typical U.K. Employers’ Liability policy and as this is a compulsory insurance, insurers would be obliged to pay a claim. However, insurers may seek recovery from the insured if they can show that the insured did not take reasonable steps to prevent such injury or illness, although it is likely that they may only succeed where the insured has acted recklessly.
Public Liability
Current policies are unlikely to contain specific pandemic exclusions, but other more general restrictive terms could be relevant, depending upon the circumstances. Insurers may look to breach of reasonable care conditions to refuse indemnity, although again it is likely that they may only succeed where the insured has acted recklessly.
It is conceivable (again depending on the circumstances) that insurers may consider whether any other potential policy restrictions may be relevant and if this proves to be the case we will provide a further update as necessary.
Public Liability insuring clauses often use either “accidental” language within their insuring clause (meaning that the onus is on the insured to prove injury etc. was accidental). They may contain Intentional or Deliberate Acts exclusions which have a similar effect, although the onus is on the insurer to prove an exclusion applies.
Business Travel Policies
Repatriation costs
Insurers may provide cover for emergency evacuation of people that are currently within the affected regions, due to a natural disaster or life-threatening situation, and if the U.K. Government advises it.
Much will depend on an insurer’s definition of ‘natural disaster’, if they have one, and if the outbreak of an infectious disease is included. Some policies provide cover in the event of political intervention, i.e. if the Government advise people to return home for safety reasons. The current situation following the outbreak of Coronavirus would probably qualify.
Disinclination to Travel
This is a common exclusion. For trips already booked but not yet commenced, it is unlikely cover would be given. However, insurers may take a different view in order to mitigate any potential claims if a person does go ahead with the journey.
Emergency Medical Costs
Cover will not be provided by insurers if people travel to regions against the advice of the Foreign Office, and subsequently become ill/infected.
However, people who become ill during journeys that are not subject to such Foreign Office advice/restrictions will be covered as per normal policy cover and conditions. It is therefore recommended that the latest Foreign Office advice is checked before arranging any journey outside the U.K.
Cancellation
Cover applies once a journey has been booked, and due to circumstances outside the insured’s control. Cover would not be given for cancelling journeys, to China for example, that are booked AFTER there is general public awareness of the Coronavirus situation.
Each applicable policy of insurance must be reviewed to determine the extent, if any, of coverage for COVID-19. Coverage may vary depending on the jurisdiction and circumstances. For global client programs it is critical to consider all local operations and how policies may or may not include COVID-19 coverage.
Produced by WTW Networks
Copyright © 2020 Willis Towers Watson. All rights reserved.
Important Note:
The information contained herein is not intended to constitute legal or other professional advice and should not be relied upon in lieu of consultation with your own legal and/or other professional advisors.
Some of the information in this publication may be compiled by third party sources we consider to be reliable, however we do not guarantee and are not responsible for the accuracy of such information. We assume no duty in contract, tort, or otherwise in connection with this publication and expressly disclaim, to the fullest extent permitted by law, any liability in connection with this publication.
Willis Towers Watson offers insurance-related services through its appropriately licensed entities in each jurisdiction in which it operates.
The information given in this publication is believed to be accurate at the date of publication 12th March 2020. This information may have subsequently changed or have been superseded, and should not be relied upon to be accurate or suitable after this date.
Members of the Willis Towers Watson Networks are authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority
Comments